See What the ‘Are You the One?’ Season 2 Alums Are Up to Now

Alex Phillips

He’s a man on a mission! After being dubbed a Perfect Match with Jasmine, the reality stars went their separate ways, and he has gone on to pursue a career in the entertainment world. Alex appeared in the TV series Apartment 9 in 2014 and Snow Jobs in 2019. The Los Angeles resident works as a comic and writer.

Anthony Bartolotte

The party boy made the most of his time on AYTO?, but things didn’t work out with Alex K. in the end. Anthony later made his debut on The Challenge in 2017 and was featured in the 2019 season of Ex on the Beach. “Doing this TV s–t is fun, but definitely not easy,” he tweeted in 2019. “It still blows my mind that this was the third different show that I’ve had the opportunity to be a part of.” He currently dates a woman named Gaby and frequently posts photos of her on his social media.

According to his Instagram, he still lives in Chicago, Illinois. 

Brandon Tindel

Brandon and Briana were each other’s Perfect Matches, but he hit it off with Christina, too. Similar to his costars, he continued his MTV fame with a stint on The Challenge in 2016. Brandon still lives in Las Vegas, Nevada, and updates his social media accounts with ab-flaunting pics and tweets about his time on AYTO?.

Curtis Hadzicki

Jenni and Curtis fell head over heels in love after filming season 2, and the spark hasn’t diminished! Although he and Briana did have a short fling post-show after his Perfect Match with Shelby, Curtis is now in a happy relationship (and engagement) with the blonde beauty. “I didn’t know I could smile this big,” Jenni gushed while showing off her dazzling new bling in their October 2020 announcement.

Dario Medrano

These days, Dario is moved on from his Perfect Match Ashley and now in a new relationship with a woman named Nathalie. After appearing on AYTO?, he was among the 2017 cast of The Challenge. His LinkedIn account and Instagram bio reveal he works as a broker and owner at Home Field Lending.

Garland Brown

Jess and Garland appeared to be a good fit for each other during the show’s finale, but they didn’t pursue a relationship after the series wrapped. The Missouri native is a proud dad and he currently makes ends meet as a model, TV personality and video game streamer. Garland still stays in touch with some of his former housemates even though they are all busy with their new lives. 

John Moustis

In week 7, viewers discovered his Perfect Match was Jenni via the Truth Booth, but they didn’t feel a strong enough connection to continue a romance. Following his time on AYTO?, John has put his Instagram account to private. His main photo seemingly indicates he could still be making music in his free time.

Layton Jones

Three’s a crowd! Layton had not one, but TWO Perfect Matches in the finale, and they were none other than Christina and Tyler A. It may not come as a surprise that nothing blossomed from that love triangle, but he appears to be content with the way everything unfolded. Layton still resides in Nashville, Tennessee, and his Instagram bio reads, “I love my God and my family unconditionally.”

Nathan Siebenmark

Nathan returned to MTV for The Challenge in 2016 and Are You the One: Second Chances in 2017. He matched with Ellie in 2014, but that didn’t end up being his leading lady after cameras stopped rolling. Nathan still posts on his social media accounts sometimes, having shared his first selfie in almost two years in 2019.

Tyler Pratt

Did Paris and Pratt go the distance? No, unfortunately they didn’t. Even though they were a Perfect Match, their chemistry fizzled out. “I just wasn’t ready for a relationship, as much as I thought I was at that time,” the now-podcaster wrote in a Q&A on December 8, 2020. “Paris was always great to me and we tried to reconnect over the years, but the timing was just never right.” He’s now in a new relationship, according to social media updates.

Alexandria Kim

After letting go of her Perfect Match Anthony, Alex embarked on a new career as a webcam model. She now lives in Seattle, Washington, according to her Twitter account. And it looks like fans will be able to catch her on OnlyFans as well. On July 7, 2021, she celebrated her fourth wedding anniversary.

Ashley Hall

Post-Dario fling, the reality star seemingly stepped away from the spotlight. She last tweeted in 2017 and appears to be enjoying her life outside of the public eye. 

Briana Lacuesta

Although her Perfect Match was Brandon, they didn’t try to take things a step further. Briana and Curtis gave it a shot, but that didn’t work out either. The San Diego resident later appeared in The Challenge and opened up about her reality TV stint in an Instagram Q&A, revealing she doesn’t plan on “reliving it” anytime soon. She now slays with her IG content and runs her own shop called ALTER. On July 16, 2021, Briana went public with her new boyfriend, writing that she’s “kept my personal life private from Instagram (unless you’re part of my close friends list) but wanted to make him public.”

Christina LeBlanc

Christina didn’t find her Mr. Right on the show, but she is now engaged to her new man, Michael Emery. “My bubby, my sweetest love… there’s nobody else id rather spend my life with. I’ll choose you everyday, for the rest of my days. I love you and I always will,” she gushed while sharing their engagement photo. The Challenge alum now has her own YouTube channel and regularly posts on Instagram.

Ellie Puckett

The dating algorithm revealed Ellie and Nathan were a Perfect Match at the end, but that didn’t exactly pan out when they returned home. Nowadays, the North Carolina native is happily married to a man named Miguel and she is the proud mom of their son, Bellamy, who lights up her life.

Jasmine Pendleton

Jasmine previously claimed Alex P. did not make a big enough effort for their long-distance relationship to work and fortunately, it seemed to be for the best. Since then, she went public with her new beau, Preston. They are still packing on PDA in cute couple photos on Instagram and she currently works as a Dental Hygienist and NLL Pro Dancer, according to her social media bio.

Jenni Knapmiller

With a wedding to plan, Jenni appears to be living her best life following her stint on AYTO?. She is making her living as a nurse and celebrating every moment spent with her husband-to-be, Curtis. “I have a feeling this next chapter is going to top the charts. I can’t wait to see it all unfold,” she wrote via Instagram in February 2020. Curtis proposed in October 2020, writing in an Instagram caption of their engagement photo, “I’ll spend the rest of my life trying to properly thank you for all that you do. I love you forever.”

Jessica Andreatta

Jessica took to Twitter after season 2 came to Netflix and revealed it’s been wild to take that trip “down memory lane” after her experience with Perfect Match Garland. “Prob not the best time to meet someone now that AYTO? is on Netflix and all over my Insta Stories, but then again, here’s my f–k it attitude,” she wrote on December 8, 2020.

Paris Eike

Paris has always been unapologetically herself and that remains true today. Following her Perfect Match-up with Pratt, the Colorado resident has gone on to pursue her own passions and is now working as a “Twitch Affiliate.” 

Shelby Yardley

As we previously mentioned, Shelby and Curtis are an item of the past. She became a successful actress in recent years, appearing in shows like The Mindy Project and Benny’s Bee Adventures. Shelby is also a creative producer and the cofounder of Wasteland Entertainment. The former Kansas local is now married to husband Brennan, having tied the knot in 2021, and a mom to adorable son Sleven.

Tyler Abron

Last but not least, Tyler A. has gone on to do great things! The Massachusetts native is an actress, college graduate and social media influencer. She appeared in a few TV series including The Family Business and The Breaks. Tyler has several projects in post-production lined up for 2021, according to her IMDB page. She later told Flaunt that fans “should be” expecting new music from her soon “along with all the other film and TV projects. I want to do it all, life’s too short. Don’t limit yourself, do it all.”