The season 8 cast of Are You The One is full of sexy, sexually fluid singles — so when they visited the In Touch offices, we knew we had to play a little game of “Would You Rather?” We sat down with Basit ShittuPaige ColeNour Fraij and Justinavery “Justin” Palm and grilled them about all of the hottest MTV stars. Which Teen Mom is the hottest mama? Who would you rather take a Double Shot at Love with? When it came time to choose, the four cast members had wildly different answers, but one thing was clear: everyone thirsts for JWowwCheck out the video above to see what (or who!) they’d rather.

For access to all our exclusive celebrity videos and interviews – Subscribe on YouTube!