Did anyone else just have a mini heart attack? Kim Kardashian took to Instagram on Wednesday, May 15, to share a photo with Lala Anthony … but fans mistook her for Kylie Jenner‘s ex-BFF, Jordyn Woods!

“Love her so much! @lala,” the Keeping Up With the Kardashians star, 38, captioned the sultry shot. In response, one fan wrote, “Totally thought that was Jordyn Woods for a second,” while another added, “Mannn, I thought that was Jordan Woods.” A third and fourth, meanwhile, chimed in, “LIKE if you thought that was Jordyn!” and, “Why did I think this was Jordyn?”

View this post on Instagram

💕 love her so much! @lala

A post shared by Kim Kardashian West (@kimkardashian) on

The snapshot came as a surprise to commenters since Kim’s sister Kylie seemingly dropped her bestie after hooking up with Khloé Kardashian‘s (now) ex-boyfriend and baby daddy, Tristan Thompson. “Tristan and Jordyn were into each other,” a source exclusively revealed to In Touch in February. “They were cuddling, holding hands. Tristan was rubbing her ass, they were definitely hooking up.” They added, “Tristan seemed concerned that the other girls at his house were watching him and Jordyn on the couch. One of Tristan’s guys told the girls no cell phone pics.”

On Tuesday, February 19, Khlo broke her silence for the first time since the scandal occurred, and media mogul Jason Lee defended the blonde beauty on Instagram. “I don’t want to hear nobody trolling Khloé talking about, ‘It’s a Kardashian curse,’ ‘It’s Khloé’s fault’ — no. If a n—a ain’t s—t, he ain’t s—t,” he said. “And Tristan, the fact that you messed around with her sister’s best friend — and the fact that Kylie, your best friend was at the house doing all of that? Get her out now. And get him out too.”

In response, Khloé’s bestie Malika Haqq wrote, “STRONG FACTS.” The Good American founder then left seven shouting emojis underneath her comments, while another family friend Larsa Pippen fumed, “Amen!!!”

It doesn’t look like Lala weighed in on the situation, but things have seemingly calmed down in recent months. In fact, Jordyn has been posting makeup-free selfies, traveling and working on growing her business. And while Koko still drops a petty message or two on the ‘Gram, here’s hoping this is all about to blow over for good.

Can’t get enough celebrity content? Be sure to subscribe to our YouTube channel for fun, exclusive videos with your favorite stars!

For access to all our exclusive celebrity videos and interviews – Subscribe on YouTube!