Voila? Jana Duggar showed her brothers how she makes cucumber salad the “Duggar way,” in a resurfaced throwback clip from Counting On, and it’s nothing short of classic. Fans are still getting a kick out of the video, showing Jana whipping up the family favorite recipe consisting of only three ingredients: cucumbers, salt, and vinegar. Fancy! Check out the video above to see her concoction. 

“Some of us like to do really thin slices,” Jana explained while chopping alongside Justin, Josiah, Joseph, and John-David. When she poured on the salt, her brothers explained how people shouldn’t use that much. “So, we add about a fourth cup of vinegar, and about, well however much salt you would like,” Jana responded, while poking fun at herself. “Sometimes, we just mix the vinegar and salt together and then you just dip your cucumbers in it.”

“Vinegar and salt? Cucumber salad in my family is cucumbers and onions in ranch dressing. I have also seen people do tomatoes and cucumbers in italian dressing. Vinegar and salt though? How bland,” one fan commented on Reddit. “To be fair, Italian dressing has vinegar as a base, but yeah, they need a bit more,” another wrote. Other fans were laughing at how they were racing to peel a cucumber the fastest. “I just find it hilarious that all those adult men have got such good cucumber peeling action,” a third joked.

The Duggars are known for showcasing their culinary skills, or what some would perceive as a lack thereof — especially Jill. She regularly shares simple recipes on her blog, even though people come out of the woodwork to throw shade at her dishes, dissing her for rarely using fresh vegetables and more! From her stuffed zucchini to her breakfast casserole, fans have been brutal with their reviews. We’ve got to hand it to the Duggar girls, because they still try! 

For more news on the Duggars, listen to our Dishin’ on the Duggars podcast below and subscribe on iTunes and Google Play.

Love the Duggars? Be sure to join our Duggars Facebook group to chat about all the latest updates and juicy gossip!