Create a free account to access exclusive content, play games, solve puzzles, test your pop-culture knowledge and receive special offers.Already have an account? Login
To fans, it seemed that the feud first began with Chantel and Pedro while waiting to go on stage to film the reunion. When Pedro asked Colt what had happened with ex Larissa Dos Santos Lima, things got messy.
2 of 22
Courtesy of Colt Johnson/Instagram
Snapping Back
When Colt responded with sarcasm and informed the couple that “love is not enough” to stave off divorce, Chantel responded, “Is it not? … Is it because you love your mama more than your ex-wife?”
3 of 22
Courtesy of Pedro Jimeno/Instagram
Couple Confrontation
When Colt told Chantel to “please shut the f–k up,” that’s when Pedro got involved, shouting at his costar not to speak to his wife like that. Meanwhile, the Georgia native was insisting she could speak for herself.
4 of 22
Courtesy of Colt Johnson/Instagram
Throwing Curses
Chantel told Colt that when people get married, they’re supposed to “leave and cleave” with their new spouse. His only response? “Chantel, you don’t know s–t, so keep your mouth shut. How about that?”
5 of 22
Courtesy of Nicole Nafziger/Instagram
Clearing the Air
Though it seemed to viewers that Chantel had been the one to start the fight by bringing Colt’s mom into it, Nicole explained the next day that Colt had actually been the instigator.
6 of 22
Courtesy of Colt Johnson/Instagram
Pointing Fingers
“He was being a jerk before we all sat down,” Nicole explained in an Instagram comment. “He was asking each couple a rude question. Like he asked me if my relationship was even real? Is that really the first thing you ask someone?”
7 of 22
Courtesy of Nicole Nafziger/Instagram
Setting the Record Straight
“He wasn’t very nice to everyone,” she continued. “He came on defense and offense. He was rude.” Explaining that Chantel had a reason to “snap,” she said, “He came at her saying rude stuff, so she gave it back to him and then he cursed her out.”
8 of 22
Courtesy of Colt Johnson/Instagram
More Drama
That wasn’t it, either. On Tuesday, July 23, a source exclusively told In Touch that there’d actually been a second altercation between Colt and Pedro — one that had almost come to blows.
9 of 22
Courtesy of Pedro Jimeno/Instagram
Getting Physical
After the first confrontation, the two men got into it again right before going out on stage. “Colt was starting with him and Pedro almost hit him,” the source said. “They were arguing up to the second they came out on set. It was quite an explosive day.”
10 of 22
Courtesy of Pedro Jimeno/Instagram
Egging On
“Colt kept saying to Pedro, ‘Come at me, come on tough guy,'” the source explained. “For some reason, Colt started with everyone individually even though no one was starting with him.”
11 of 22
Courtesy of Ashley Martson/Instagram
Picking Fights
Another costar he butted heads with was Ashley. “He asked Ashley if she had scammed anyone lately and called her ‘Trashley,'” said the insider. “it actually was more explosive than the fight they showed with Chantel, as Ashley was yelling at him much louder than Chantel yelled at him.”
12 of 22
Courtesy of Ashley Martson/Instagram
Fed Up
When the blonde beauty got sat next to Colt on stage, she lost her patience again. “She was like, ‘Oh for f–k’s sake, seriously?’ … They also didn’t show that,” the insider spilled.
13 of 22
Courtesy of Colt Johnson/Instagram
Standing His Ground
When In Touch reached out to Colt to confirm the report, he neglected to weigh in on the fight with Pedro, but backed up the rest of it. “Yes, I can exclusively confirm to you that I did indeed call Ashley ‘Trashley,'” he said.
14 of 22
Courtesy of Ashley Martson/Instagram
Harsh Words
That wasn’t all he had to say, though. Colt continued to drag all of his costars off screen. “[Ashley] scammed all of her fans on multiple occasions,” he alleged.
15 of 22
Courtesy of Nicole Nafziger/Instagram
Call Out
“Nicole has been in a long-distance relationship for many years without any sign of progression or interest in getting married,” he said about his comments regarding her and Azan Tefou‘s relationship.
16 of 22
Courtesy of Pedro Jimeno/Instagram
Slamming Stars
He saved his harshest criticism for Chantel, neglecting to mention Pedro at all. “Chantel is a hypocrite and literally is human noise,” he finished before encouraging fans to “keep watching.”
17 of 22
Courtesy of Ashley Martson/Instagram
Fighting Back
His costars weren’t about to take those jabs lying down, though. In exclusive statements shared with In Touch, both Ashley and Nicole responded with exactly what they thought of the barbs.
18 of 22
Courtesy of Ashley Martson/Instagram
No Holds Barred
“Disregard his nonsense,” Ashley told In Touch. “He’s suffering from little dick syndrome. … He’s just butthurt he didn’t get funds to support his porn addiction.”
19 of 22
Courtesy of Nicole Nafziger/Instagram
Mature Words
Nicole also wanted to respond to his claims. “It doesn’t matter how many years [I’ve been with Azan],” she said. “My relationship is my own with the person I am with.”
20 of 22
Courtesy of Nicole Nafziger/Instagram
All Love
“No one is allowed to judge me because our process is different and taking longer than other 90 Day [couples]. … I don’t judge other cast members, and I would hope they felt the same way to not judge my relationship.”
21 of 22
Courtesy of Colt Johnson/Instagram
Problematic Person
“I only know the cast members when I meet them in person,” she continued. “Everyone was really nice except Colt. He came ready to be rude. You could tell by the way he was taking jabs at everyone.”
22 of 22
Courtesy of Nicole Nafziger/Instagram
Final Word
Beyond that, Nicole decided to reserve judgment and keep whatever thoughts she may have about Colt to herself. But it’s clear that she and Ashley were the ones getting the last word — at least until part two of the tell-all sparks even more drama.
