It’s All or Nothing! ‘Married at First Sight’ Couples Who Divorced Before Decision Day

Clare and Cameron

While MAFS fans were convinced Clare and Cameron’s marriage was salvageable, the pair failed to find the “spark” in their relationship and bumped heads when it came to important topics like religion and raising children. Clare and Cameron called it quits just 31 days into the experiment.

Lauren Goodger and Orion Martzloff

Season 17 couple Lauren Goodger and Orion Martzloff did not make it, surprising few fans of the show.

Heather Seidel and Derek Schwartz

Season 4 couple Heather Seidel and Derek Schwartz only lasted 10 days before calling it quits.

Olivia Cornu and Brett Lindsey

The tension between season 11 couple Olivia Cornu and Brett Lindsey came to a head midseason when Brett moved out of their New Orleans apartment and took everything – including the food – with him.

Alyssa and Chris

Alyssa and Chris’ relationship lasted less than two weeks before the couple’s “I do” turned into “I don’t,” though she maintained throughout the show that she’s “a good person!”

Morgan Bell and Binh Trinh

Season 15’s Morgan Bell and Binh Trinh seemingly hit it off at their nuptials; however, after Binh shared private information his new wife told him with another cast member and claimed that she was lying about being a nurse, Morgan lost all trust for her husband and the pair eventually split on their one-month anniversary.

Dom and Mack

Dom and Mack – whose nearly decade age difference was a cause of concern amongst fans early on – didn’t have what it took to stick it out until Decision Day. 

“Our time was cut short and that really sucked,” Mack told People in March 2023. “I can’t say I’m glad I got a divorce or anything, because as you see in the show, I did feel let down. It sucks to be portrayed as a loser without his own place, but that’s on me.”