This is a little awkward. Despite his past claims, Lindsay Lohan denied ever hooking up with Vanderpump Rules star Jax Taylor during an episode of Watch What Happens Live with Andy Cohen on Jan. 9, Us Weekly reported. In fact, she said they’d never even met. Huh?

During a segment of “Plead the Fifth” on the show, Lisa Vanderpump asked, “How would you describe Jax as a lover?” Lindsay, 32, responded, “Lisa, I love you but I’ve never even met him. I never met him, really, yes.” She then quipped, “Maybe he met, like, Annie or Hallie,” referring to her Parent Trap characters.

jax taylor watch what happens live
Getty Images

Jax, 39, claimed he and Lindsay had hooked up during a December 2017 interview with The Daily Dish, Us Weekly reported on Dec. 22, 2017. “There was a little situation,” Jax began, “I think it was when she got married to Samantha Ronson, like a week later. That was around that time. It was at a nightclub, we just ended up back at her spot, and it was what it was.” (For the record, Lindsay and Samantha dated but were never married, so what is he even talking about?)

He also claimed he ran into Lindsay at a DailyMail holiday party earlier that same month and that he didn’t recognize her in the slightest. “I mean, I really didn’t recognize her,” he said at the time. “She looks great. Just a lot different.”

But Lindsay said that not only have the two never hooked up, but they also didn’t even remotely meet the two times Jax seems to recall. On Watch What Happens, Andy Cohen, 50, asked the actress, “you’re calling Jax Taylor a liar?” Lindsay simply replied, “yep, yes.” Hmm.

Jax later responded to Lindsay’s comments in a tweet. It included a screenshot of him seemingly texting with a friend about Lindsay’s claims and the caption, “Not that I care, it was over 10 years ago and I am happily engaged… but she’s a liar, my two friends who have nothing to gain, were with me the whole night. That’s all I will say on this. So you are lying darlin.”

So what’s really the truth here? Did Jax and Lindsay meet and she just doesn’t remember it? Is Jax thinking of someone else? Or did one or both of the stars make some of this up? We may never know the full story.