Things are getting off to a thorny start for The Bachelorette Rachel Lindsay. As In Touch previously reported, several of Rachel’s suitors have had run-ins with the law and been accused of cheating. Now In Touch has learned that two of the men dated the same girl.

Season 13 contestants Blake Elarbee, 31, and Lucas Yancey, 30, appeared on Ex Isle together in 2016.

MORE: Corrine Olympios Slams Nick and Vanessa's Relationship — Find out What She Said

“Lucas brought his ex-girlfriend Brittney on the [WEtv reality] show, but during filming she hit it off with Blake,” says a source, adding that the pair briefly dated and even lived together after filming ended.

rachel lindsay getty images

Not surprisingly, “These guys do not get along in real life. Producers must have cast them on purpose because it’ll make for good TV!”

MORE: Jade Roper Debuts Her Baby Bump — See the Adorable Pic

Rachel “can tell that many of these guys are just there to become famous,” says an insider, adding that she is so disappointed with her selection of men this season.

For more on this, pick up the latest issue of In Touch — and for more exclusive content sign up for our newsletter!