A new Instagram post from Jill Duggar definitely didn’t go as planned on Dec. 29! The Counting On star simply wanted to show fans a sweet marriage moment where hubby Derick Dillard was giving her a foot massage, but the sweet gesture was quickly overshadowed by the fact that it looks like Jill has an extra toe! Watch the video below to see the shocking image!

Of course, while some fans were focused on the sixth toe and Derick being “creepy,” others were supportive, as always. “What a sweet husband! Love comes in many forms… a foot rub is a small but sweet gesture of love! Praise the lord for those selfless gestures,” said a fan. We’ve got to be honest, for a family who preaches about women honoring their men and doing everything for them, it’s nice to see Derick catering to his wife and pampering her for once, extra toes or not.

However, some fans are using the pic to accuse Derick of having some sort of deranged foot fetish. Jill used the hashtag #footrub, which also happens to link to some fetish photos on Instagram. “Do you think Jill was barefoot at her wedding bcuz she wanted to be?” said one hater. “Derick is one sick man who hides behind the bible. He knows and Jill knows that the hashtag she used, will have this pic on a foot fetish site.” Sheesh, that seems a little extreme.

One thing we’re glad to see? Derick seems to have shopped off his weirdo bowl haircut and traded it for a more mature crew cut. “Yay, nice haircut!!” said one excited supporter, while another agreed, saying “Derick looks sooooo much better with his haircut.” We must admit, he looks a lot better this way (even if he’s still a controversial jerk at heart!)