Is she or isn’t she?! It’s the age-old question that has plagued Counting On fans for months. Jana Duggar — the oldest daughter of the reality star family — and Caleb Williams have been rumored to be courting ever since he was spotted in family photos. Most recently, he was seen enjoying a football game with Jim Bob on Oct. 21, and he has even met Josh and Anna Duggar’s youngest son, Mason. Since potential suitors must get Jim Bob’s approval before entering a courtship with a Duggar daughter, it makes sense that Caleb is so buddy-buddy with the fam.

Unfortunately, Caleb doesn’t get the stamp of approval from fans. Internet trolls were pretty quick to pick apart Caleb’s appearance — slamming him for his “sloppy” look and calling him out for showing his underwear in a recent photo. One commenter wrote, “I can see the top of his underwear. Lol.” Another added, “Who’s the guy on the left in front? Don’t think he’s a Dugger – his blue underwear, etc. is showing.” Harsh! Caleb quickly fired back at his haters, “To all the folks out there wondering: No, I had no idea my unmentionables were hanging out. In the future, I will probably triple check to verify the integrity of my outer garments before any such pictures are snapped and shared,” he wrote.

Courting — which is defined as being “involved with romantically, typically with the intention of marrying” — is something the family takes seriously. Yet according to RadarOnline, when asked if Caleb follows courtship rules such as giving side hugs when engaged, the insider confessed, “Not really.” Gasp!

In fact, her potential man is pretty liberal, something the Duggars, well, aren’t. According to RadarOnline, “They have similar belief systems, but he’s a bit different in his thinking. He’s maybe somewhat more liberal.” We wonder how Jim Bob feels about that!

Then again, the Duggars — including matriarch Michelle! — have been rebelling against their conservative ways these days. Michelle was recently spotted wearing pants — a huge no-no in the Bible, apparently? — and Jill Duggar got a nose piercing. She even got a tattoo as well!

TBH, we can’t keep up with this family. Then again, when there are 19 kids to keep track of, can you blame us?

Jinger Duggar — aka the OG rebel of the family — has also been rocking pants. See her “revealing” outfits by watching the video below!

Have a tip? Send it to us! Email In Touch at