See Nancy Juvonen and Jimmy Fallon’s Complete Relationship Timeline Amid Marriage Woes

2004

Although sparks didn’t fly immediately between the pair, Nancy recalled her first impression of Jimmy as nothing short of a warm welcome.

“I kind of crept in [the set of SNL] quietly, and all of a sudden Jimmy goes, ‘Hey Nancy! You’re Nancy? Hi, it’s so nice to meet you, welcome!’” she said during her 2020 appearance on The Tonight Show. “And I felt just so embraced and cool, like, ‘Thank you! Thank you for welcoming me in. This is so nice, it’s so intimidating [here].’”

2005

Offcamera lovers! Although the late-night talk show host had an onscreen romance with Drew in Fever Pitch, his heart grew for Nancy, who produced the movie, in real life.

Jimmy reflected on the early stages of developing feelings for Nancy while filming, comparing her to a “neon [person]” who “stood out in this gray [background].”

2007

Jimmy proposed to Nancy in August while they visited her family in New Hampshire. Though they were planning to tie the knot in the coming years, the pair got married that December after their “dream” wedding destination opened up.

Billionaire Richard Branson offered to rent Jimmy and Nancy his residence, Necker Island, for three days while he visited family for Christmas. With no hesitation, the couple said “yes” and were on their way to say, “I do.”

“We got this place for three days, so Jimmy goes, ‘What if we got married in three weeks, instead of next summer?'” Juvonen said during her 2020 appearance on The Tonight Show. “And I’m like, ‘This is the best idea of all human time.’ So, we had 12 people at our wedding. I just got a dress done as fast as I could. We didn’t care.”

“We couldn’t invite people! There are some aunts that don’t talk to us to this day,” Jimmy revealed.

“It was us, brother, sister, best friend and parents. And man, we had a rager time. It was so much fun. Hands down, one of the best days and nights of my entire life.”

2013

Jimmy and Nancy entered parenthood after they welcomed daughter Winnie Rose via surrogate on July 23, 2013.

2014

Less than one year later, Winnie gained a big sister after her parents welcomed daughter Frances Cole via surrogate on December 3, 2014.

2023

After almost 20 years together, the couple faced relationship woes after sources exclusively told In Touch that their “marriage is in crisis” in October.

“Jimmy and Nancy have always had a contentious relationship, but it’s been particularly bad recently,” an insider explained, before hinting that the family matriarch would “take every penny” if they ever got divorced. “Especially during the writers’ strike they were fighting a lot, arguing over money, living arrangements and his drinking. She’s very, very controlling and it’s taking a toll.”

A second source also revealed that Jimmy is “always drinking and rowdy” during solo outings on the town while Nancy is at home with their daughters. “He would jump on stage and sing, take pics, he was not subtle,” the ​second source shared. “Nancy has let him get away with murder in the past – she partied hard with him back in the day. And he always had a lot of freedom. But this is different, they’re never together.”

November 2023

Jimmy is now on the path to improvement. A source told Life & Style that the actor is “picking up the pieces” in his marriage and at the office after he was accused of creating a toxic work environment earlier this year.

“Jimmy is turning over a new leaf – he apologized to his staff, is making family time a priority and has sought out counseling to change old patterns that don’t suit him any longer,” the insider revealed, later adding that “family now comes first” for the talk show host.

“Jimmy’s focus is to not get overwhelmed and take it out on others, at work or at home. You can already see the difference in him,” the source concluded.