Bachelorette DeAnna Pappas and her fiancé, Jesse Csincsak, are getting married next year — and in a twist befitting their reality TV romance, former Bachelor Andy Baldwin will perform the ceremony! “Andy is a certified minister,” the insider explains, noting that the rose ceremony veterans met on MySpace and got so close that Andy was asked to officiate at the wedding. “I’m really so happy for DeAnna and Jesse. I am really honored that they’ve asked me and I can’t wait to be a part of their big day,” Andy tells In Touch. Andy was on The Bachelor a year before DeAnna lost as a contestant, later starring on The Bachelorette.

For more check out the new In Touch, on sale now.