It has been long speculated that O.J. Simpson murdered his ex-wife Nicole Brown Simpson and her friend Ron Goldman, even though he was found not guilty decades ago. And now Caitlyn Jenner has claimed that her wife at the time, Kris Jenner knew the athlete was guilty of the horrific 1994 crime.

The 68-year-old recounted her recollection of that dark period during a chat with Kyle and Jackie O on their radio KIIS FM show. “We pretty much knew he was guilty right from the beginning, but the whole thing was, ‘Is he going to get away with it?’” she said on the phone.

Caitlyn recounted a chat Kim Kardashian’s mom had with Nicole just weeks before she was brutally murdered. “He says he’s going to kill me and get away with it because he’s O.J. Simpson,” the former Olympian said of Kris’ alleged conversation with her late best friend.

“At the time, she brushed it off and was like, ‘Come on, please, please, please. But unfortunately, it was right.” Kris and a then-Bruce Jenner truly believed that O.J. Simpson would pay for the two murders.

View this post on Instagram

To the greatest of the great… miss you everyday!

A post shared by Khloé (@khloekardashian) on

But the NFL great, who was represented by Kris’ ex-husband Rob Kardashian, was found not guilty. “We were in [prosecutor] Marcia Clark’s office at the courthouse when the verdict came down,” Caitlyn recalled.

This post was written by Chloe Lal. It originally appeared on our sister site, Now to Love.

For access to all our exclusive celebrity videos and interviews – Subscribe on YouTube!