She’s stuck in the middle! Nikki Bella and Brie Bella are known for their fights both in the ring and out, and they definitely got into it during the season premiere of their Total Divas spin-off Total Bellas. Nikki defended her man John Cena after Brie said that she didn’t feel like he was part of the family — and she exclusively revealed to In Touch what it’s like to be caught in the middle between her twin sister and her man. Watch the video below to find out why it’s hard for Nikki to choose sides!

On tonight’s episode, fans caught up with the Bella Twins and their Bella fam — including mom Kathy Colace and her husband John Laurinaitis, their brother JJ Garcia and his wife Lauren Garcia, Nikki’s longtime love John and Brie’s husband, SmackDown LIVE general manager Daniel Bryan. Last season, Brie and Bryan moved from their home in Arizona into John’s home in Florida in order to help Nikki and John heal from their respective surgeries — and now, the tables have turned.

Brie asked Nikki and John to temporarily move to Arizona so they could help her prepare for the birth of her baby daughter Birdie Joe, and so Nikki could be closer to Brie as they worked on launching their new business — a lingerie and clothing boutique called Birdiebee and their own brand of wine, Belle Radici — but John couldn’t commit to relocating with his busy schedule.

It looks like Brie will have to start accepting John as part of the family — after years of being adamant that he did not want to remarry, the Trainwreck star got down on one knee and popped the question to Nikki in the middle of the ring during Wrestlemania 33 back in April. But will Brie accept him as a soon-to-be brother-in-law? Fans will have to tune in to Season 2 of Total Bellas, airing Wednesdays at 9 p.m. on E! to find out.