Who Is Jenn Potthast? Meet ’90 Day Fiance’ Star Elizabeth’s Sister Amid Josh Weinstein Dating Rumors

Die-hard 90 Day Fiancé fans may be familiar with Jennifer “Jenn” Potthast, who did not share her own love story on the show but appeared alongside sister Elizabeth “Libby” Castravet (née Potthast) in season 5 of the flagship series in 2017. It’s been a while since Jenn’s name has popped up within the franchise, yet in March 2025, the former TV personality sparked dating rumors with fellow 90 Day Fiancé star Josh Weinstein. Now, fans are hoping to learn more about her.

Who Is ‘90 Day Fiance’ Star Libby Potthast’s Sister Jenn Potthast?

Jenn made appearances on both 90 Day Fiancé season 5 and 90 Day Fiancé: Happily Ever After? seasons 4 through 7. She was against her sister’s relationship with Andrei Castravet from the start, believing that he wasn’t a good match for Libby. She also thought he was using Libby to be able to come to America for a better life.

Many 90 Day Fiancé fans saw Jenn as a villain due to some of the comments she made on the show. For example, during a 2020 episode of Happily Ever After?, Jenn faced backlash for calling Andrei’s family’s Moldovan cooking “peasant food.” She later responded to the criticism on Instagram.

“OK, so, you guys gotta understand something. Literally just getting off a long-ass flight, coming in, meeting a million people for the first time, film crew in your face, you haven’t eaten anything normal — normal to me, anyway, I’m sorry if I’m offending people — but going in and just being mentally mind-f–ked and then having food in your face that you’ve never seen before in terms of, like, a piece of pig fat on a cracker — raw pig fat — [I am] just not used to that,” she wrote on her Instagram Stories at the time. “[I] didn’t feel like eating it. I’m sorry. And you guys are just going bonkers about it. Like, chill. Chill. Because if you were in that situation, you wouldn’t eat it either. So stop.”

Jenn Weinstein Was Married to DJ Orlando Davis

While’s own marriage didn’t play out on the 90 Day Fiancé franchise like her sister’s, she was previously married to Florida-based radio DJ Orlando Davis before he filed for divorce in 2011, In Touch exclusively confirmed in 2022.

Orlando is the host of the daily radio show “Orlando and the Freakshow” on WiLD 94.1, which broadcasts to the Tampa and St. Petersburg areas. He is “one of the leading program directors and air personalities in the country,” according to his radio station bio.

Orlando and Jenn’s divorce was finalized on September 1, 2011, according to court documents obtained by In Touch. The exes were granted joint parental responsibility for their two daughters, Kaelyn and Brielle.

During their marriage, Orlando and Jenn butted heads over their daughters appearing on 90 Day Fiancé. “I think the show is trash,” the DJ said on his “Freakshow Daily Podcast” in September 2022. “I think our family, my extended family on her side, has jumped in both feet, and they’re like, ‘Yo, we don’t mind, there are some benefits to being involved in some trashy TV.’ So they’re cool with it [and] I’m like, ‘Leave my daughters out of it.’”

90 Day Fiance’s Josh Weinstein Sparks Dating Rumors With Jenn Potthast

Jenn sparked romance rumors with Josh when she appeared alongside the modeling CEO in an Instagram Story that showed the pair sipping on drinks and posing together, as seen in a screen recording shared by fan account 90 Day Fiancé Update on March 2, 2025.

“Josh Weinstein’s 90-Day Fiance mystery lady may have been revealed. Has he been hiding her for years?” the caption read. “This is Elizabeth Potthast‘s sister, Jenn, remember her? Josh actually knows their family since Elizabeth’s mom runs a casting agency. What do you all think? Does it look like a match made in heaven? P.S. He tagged Jenn on her IG.”

Days after the post, Josh revealed in the 90 Day: The Last Resort season 2 tell-all trailer that he was dating someone new following his split from Natalie Mordovtseva.

“Well, you know, I do like somebody a lot. We’ve been hanging out a lot,” he told host Shaun Robinson, who teased that the mystery woman was a familiar face.

“Some of you might recognize her already,” Shaun said after noting that the woman was invited to speak at the tell-all.