Much like your high school boyfriend—or that cavity you’ve been neglecting—MySpace is one of those things that is really, really easy to forget about… but as soon as you remember it, it somehow comes back to haunt you in the most painful way possible.

We took a trip via a time machine (A.K.A. the Internet) to stalk some of our favorite star’s old pages—and they’re too good not to share!

And let this serve as a friendly reminder—next time you’re sharing belfies on Facebook and posting #NoFilter shots on Instagram, remember: Nothing ever really dies on the Interwebz!

(h/t Refinery29)