Did anyone else do a double-take when they first saw Caelynn Miller-Keyes on The Bachelor? We knew we recognized her from somewhere, but we couldn’t quite place where. When we saw her again on Bachelor in Paradise, it finally hit us: She looks just like Jessa Duggar. And we’re not the only ones who think so. Ever since the blonde beauty started her search for love on reality TV, fans can’t stop talking about how she looks like she belongs on TLC.

“Caelynn looks like she could be a Duggar sister,” tweeted one fan. “Is Caelynn a member of the Duggar family????!” added another. A third chimed in, “I watched The Bachelor for the first time this season, and my takeaway is that Caelynn is actually Jessa Duggar wearing a ~very~ light disguise.” Ultimately, we think this fan put it best: “Once you realize that Caelynn is the long lost slutty Duggar sister, you can’t unsee it.”

Side-by-Side Photos of Caelynn Miller-Keyes and Jessa Duggar
Courtesy of Caelynn Miller-Keyes/Instagram; the Duggar family/YouTube

We’d hardly call the 24 year old “slutty,” but when you contrast her with her Counting On counterparts, it’s clear the reality TV family would be scandalized. After all, the Bachelor Nation alum is on a show where the whole point is to date a bunch of people on a beach where the only activities are swimming in skimpy bikinis, tossing back margs and making out with hotties. That breaks just about every Duggar rule in the book. Compared to the Duggar daughters, who don’t even hold hands with a boy until they’re engaged to him, Caelynn is straight up freaky.

Now that we’ve seen the resemblance, though, we can’t stop thinking about an alternate reality where the stars are actually related. If Caelynn lived in Duggar world, she’d already be settled down by now — and she might even have a kid or two. Meanwhile, if Jana Duggar could just make the jump to the Bachelor world, she might be well on her way to finding her Prince Charming. Anyone else rooting for the oldest daughter to take her rightful place as the next star of The Bachelorette?

For more news on the Duggars, listen to our “Dishin’ On The Duggars” podcast below and subscribe on iTunes and Google Play.

Have a tip? Send it to us! Email In Touch at contact@intouchweekly.com.