When Andi Dorfman served as ABC's Bachelorette in 2014, she left contestant Nick Viall in shock by choosing to spend "forever" with former pro athlete Josh Murray. But according to her best selling book, It's Not Okay, the runner-up's fate was decided by his antics in the bedroom!
Andi explains that her one and only sexual encounter with the former software sales exec happened during their overnight date in the Fantasy Suite. Instead of saying he loved her like she expected, Nick started a game of "Would you rather?" (yep, in the middle of sex!)
"Would you rather make love... or f--k?" he asked a very surprised Andi. "Ummm... make love," she responded, to which he replied, "Well, if I had four times, I'd like to f--k the first three times and make love the fourth."
As Andi describes it, that night was the "most cringe-worthy, lady boner-killing, awkward" experience of her life.
And while she didn't end up engaged to Nick, her romance with Josh (or Number Twenty-Six as she refers to him in the book) didn't end so happily ever after either.
Now, nearly three years later, Nick is the one handing out the roses as the latest Bachelor — and he's reuniting with his former flame on the small screen once again. The former assistant district attorney makes an unexpected cameo in the upcoming episode, airing on Monday — and we can only imagine how awkward their interaction is going to be!
For more details on Andi's reality TV past, order your own copy of It's Not Okay here!