How He Stole Our Hearts Then: We’re assuming you’ve seen She’s All That—in which case we shouldn’t even have to explain our love for Freddie Prinze Jr.! Not to mention Head Over Heels, Boys and Girls and Summer Catch!
He’s the king of romantic comedies, so it’s no surprise that he tops the list of ‘90s men who stole our hearts!
Unfortunately—for us, that is—FPJ has been happily married to fellow ‘90s icon Sarah Michelle Gellar, whom he met filming I Know What You Did Last Summer. They tied the knot in September 2002, and have since welcomed two children together, Charlotte, 4, and Rocky, 21 months.