She may have been criticized for her lackluster performance on So You Think You Can Dance, but one of the show's real judges was impressed with Katie Holmes' moves. "I was amazed at the people that said, 'She's not as good as the dancers.' Well, of course she's not. She's not trained as a dancer. She's an actress!" the Fox hit's judge Nigel Lythgoe said about Katie to In Touch at Burn the Floor's Broadway premiere in New York on August 2. "For a non-singer and non-dancer, she was absolutely fabulous." Nigel commended Katie for her Judy Garland-inspired number for the program's 100th episode on July 23, which raised funds for the Dizzy Feet Foundation. "I can only thank her for laying herself out there. She's courageous in doing that," Nigel added.