Tyler first sparked infidelity accusations when a blind item on Crazy Days and Nights suggested he stepped out on his wife, though MTV cameras chose to ignore the situation because it "doesn’t fit in the story line for this season for the couple."
Farrah, who will now appear on Marriage Boot Camp Reality Stars: Family Edition alongside her parents, Michael Abraham and Debra Danielsen, does think the rumors are true.
"Yeah probably with a gay guy! Okay, that's my thought. You need a minute to digest that," she said during a Facebook Live interview with In Touch.
Back in February, the famous father tweeted that "it was dark and he was drunk" so he couldn't remember if the ~encounter~ happened with a guy or girl — though we were sure he was joking!
"Well since it's out in the open @TylerBaltierra did cheat on me he's busted," Cate tweeted at the time.
For more exclusive content, sign up for the In Touch newsletter!
Scroll through the gallery to see more of Farrah's most outrageous quotes.