Kristy Lee Cook got the surprise of her life after being eliminated from American Idol on April 16. Her boyfriend, Andrew, proposed for the second time on live TV during the taping of Fox Reality Channel’s American Idol Extra. “I had no clue he was going to pop the question,” she says. Andrew proposed for the first time on March 15, but this time he got down on one knee and presented his future wife with a marquise-cut diamond ring. “There’s no date yet, but we’re planning it for around next June,” says Kristy.