Stars like Halle Berry and Eva Mendes gathered at the High Line in New York City to celebrate Calvin Klein’s 40th anniversary on September 7. Brooke Shields actually arrived wearing the same jeans she modeled when she was 15 for her Calvin Klein ads! There’s no denying that all of the ads are unforgettable, so In Touch wanted to know which Calvin Klein model the stars love the most.

Molly Sims
“Mark Wahlberg in his underwear — that was a good one.”

Matt Dallas
“Brooke Shields is a classic with her, ‘Nothing comes between me and my Calvins.’ But the one that stood out to me the most is Hilary Swank in the bra. It was just like, ‘Whoa.’”

Lindsay Price
“Brooke Shields, naturally.”

Rachel Zoe
“Kate Moss ads. I think Calvin’s ads are constantly groundbreaking. Sexy and simple.”

Kimora Lee Simmons
“I think Djimon [Hounsou]’s ad is the best. He is the only guy of color. Which I think is amazing and very necessary.”

Tell us who your favorite Calvin Klein Model is and why — just e-mail Fashion Writer Amy Silverberg at fashionista@intouchweekly.com. And remember, Stay Stylish!