Aubrey O’Day only recently joined the cast of Hairspray on Broadway, but she’s already found love with co-star Ashley Parker Angel, 26. “They’ve known each other for a while and now they’re hooking up,” reveals an insider. Of the budding romance, Aubrey, 24, coyly tells In Touch, “Only time will tell.” But a pal says it’s serious. “She’s been bragging to her friends about how cute he is and even brought him to Pop Burger after the show on July 17.” Ashley and Aubrey both started their careers on MTV’s Making the Band.

For more check out the new In Touch, on sale now!